Tim Creasey ATT
- VAT Senior Manager
- +44 (0)330 124 1399
- Email Tim
A recent Court of Appeal decision has reignited debate around the VAT treatment of grant funding and public sector payments.
While the case concerned a further education college, its implications could extend well beyond the education sector, making it relevant to charities and not-for-profit organisations that receive grants or public funding to deliver services.
The decision highlights a long-standing VAT risk: funding described as a “grant” may not always be treated as non-business income if there is a sufficient link between the funding received and the services provided. In some cases, this can affect VAT recovery, charitable VAT reliefs and, potentially, create unexpected VAT liabilities.
Importantly, HMRC has confirmed in Revenue & Customs Brief 3 (2026) that it will not appeal the judgment and is considering its implications. For further education institutions that have continued to treat the relevant funding as non-business income, HMRC has confirmed that any change in VAT treatment will apply prospectively from a future date yet to be announced. Its wider policy on grant funding remains unchanged at present. However, the case serves as a timely reminder that the precise terms and operation of funding arrangements remain critical when determining the correct VAT treatment.
In HMRC v Colchester Institute Corporation [2026], the Court of Appeal considered funding received by Colchester Institute from government agencies to provide free education and vocational training to eligible learners.
Historically, HMRC viewed this type of funding as non-business grant income, with the associated activities falling outside the scope of VAT. The Institute argued that the funding instead represented third-party consideration for educational services supplied to students, with government agencies effectively paying on the students’ behalf.
The Court of Appeal agreed with the Institute and concluded that there was a sufficiently direct link between the funding received and the educational services provided. As a result, the funded activities were treated as exempt business supplies rather than non-business activities.
While the decision was reached in an education context, it reinforces the importance of understanding when funding may constitute consideration for a supply for VAT purposes.
For some organisations, a change in the VAT characterisation of funded activities could have significant consequences.
Many charities rely on activities being non-business when accessing reliefs such as:
Zero-rating for the construction of buildings intended for use solely for a relevant charitable purpose, subject to the applicable statutory conditions and permitted non-qualifying use.
The reduced rate (temporarily zero rated) of VAT on qualifying fuel and power supplies used for non-business charitable activities.
If activities previously regarded as non-business are instead classified as business activities, entitlement to these reliefs could be affected.
The decision may be of particular interest to further education colleges, and other education providers, including academies, nurseries, independent schools and SEND providers, that receive government or local authority funding linked to educational services. However, the implications will depend on the nature of the provider, the funding arrangements and the VAT treatment of the underlying education.
Where grant-funded activities are reclassified from non-business activities to exempt business supplies, this could affect how organisations recover input VAT. Both business/non-business apportionment and partial exemption calculations may need to be revisited, potentially changing the amount of VAT recoverable on associated costs.
Although the case concerns education funding, the principles may be relevant wherever charities receive funding from government departments, local authorities, NHS bodies or other public sector organisations.
Examples could include charities providing:
As we have highlighted previously, the VAT treatment of funding depends on the commercial reality rather than the label attached to a payment. A payment described as a “grant” will not necessarily be treated as non-business funding if there is a direct link between the funding and identifiable services being provided.
Where funding is closely linked to specific services, outputs, performance measures or beneficiary numbers, there may be a greater risk that the funding could be viewed as consideration for a supply.
Depending on the circumstances, this could result in income being treated as consideration for either exempt or taxable supplies, potentially affecting VAT recovery, charitable reliefs and, in some cases, creating an output VAT liability.
At present, charities should not assume that existing grant funding arrangements have changed VAT status as a result of the Colchester Institute decision. HMRC has been clear that its wider policy position remains unchanged.
However, organisations receiving significant grant or public sector funding may wish to review key funding agreements and consider factors such as:
Funding arrangements that sit close to the boundary between grant funding and contracted services may warrant a more detailed VAT review.
Tim Creasey, VAT Senior Manager says: “While HMRC has confirmed that the Colchester Institute judgment does not change its wider policy on grant funding, the case is a useful reminder that VAT treatment depends on the substance of the arrangements, not simply what the funding is called. Charities receiving significant grant funding should ensure the underlying agreements support the VAT treatment being applied.”
Further Reading: This case reinforces many of the principles discussed in our earlier article, “Grant or payment for services? Why getting this right really matters“. While HMRC maintains that its established approach to grant funding remains unchanged, the judgment highlights the importance of looking beyond labels and considering the practical operation of funding arrangements when assessing their VAT treatment.
If your charity receives grant funding or public sector payments, our VAT specialists can help you review your funding arrangements, understand the potential implications of the Colchester Institute ruling and ensure your VAT treatment is appropriate. Get in touch to discuss how we can support your organisation.
Share this article
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Related people
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Our complimentary newsletters and event invitations are designed to provide you with regular updates, insight and guidance.
You can unsubscribe from our email communications at any time by emailing [email protected] or by clicking the 'unsubscribe' link found on all our email newsletters and event invitations.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.